Posted in Fallen Earth

Fallen Earth free is fine by me

GamersFirst has both announced the launch date for Fallen Earth’s free-to-play model (October 12th) as well as presented a more informative (but not yet fully complete) chart of payment plans and subsequent affects on the game.  Looking it over, I feel like I’m getting away with something huge by gravitating to the completely free option, like I want to be chuckling in glee but worried that the publisher will realize its mistake and yank it away from me.

From the sounds of some other bloggers, Fallen Earth is becoming an enticing prospect once again as well.  While playing, I’ve been watching the Help chat tackle this issue over and over again.  Veterans seem split down the line: Some are genuinely excited for F2P, hoping that it’ll bring in a lot more players and extend the life of the game they love; some are despairing that the freebies will be uncouth savages that’ll ruin their playground.  You know, the now-standard anticipation response to a F2P conversion.  Personally, I side with the former crowd — Fallen Earth does not have that big of a population (I heard 5K bandied about at one point, but I have no idea), and if it isn’t made more viable, this great game’s going to be headed for the dumpster sooner rather than later.  Plus, free players aren’t and shouldn’t be stereotyped into a “bad” lump; like any group of players, they contain the good and the bad.

In short, the free version looks perfect for me and where I’m at as a gamer.  Let’s take a closer look:

The stuff we get: I liked a comment someone made on a Massively FE post, in response to the whining that they didn’t get more with the free model: “How much daily crafting time do you get for free now? How much mail and auction access do you get for free now? How much EXP and AP gain do you get for free now? How much local chat do you get for free now?  So, to clear things up, basically you’re crying like a spoiled little baby because they’re planning to give people a bunch of stuff for free which currently costs money, but you think they should give you even more?”

That’s how I feel.

Looking the chart over, it’s really cool just how much we get: All of the game’s content (no locked zones or purchasable quests or restrictions on vehicles and combat and weapons), all the skills, full level cap.  Free players can even form clans, access mail, and use the auction house, which most F2P conversions tend to deny. It’s even kind of generous that free players will get a meager 50 reward points a month for, y’know, doing nothing.  It’s not much, but it’s far more than I expected.

Now, it says “limited” chips, but GamersFirst qualified that by saying that if you ever subscribed or spent any money on the game, that limitation would go away.  So that’s nice and not a personal concern of mine.

Crafting is a big issue that a lot of the F2P discussion’s revolved around.  Since crafting is one of the big cornerstones of the FE experience, these limitations may seem a bit harsh at first.  8 hours of crafting a day, slower crafting speed, slower harvesting speed, slower salvaging speed.  Yeah, I’ll admit, that will chafe — but it’s something I could get used to, as well, in exchange for its free cost point.  It only becomes restricting when you compare it to what others have, and Fallen Earth doesn’t feel like a gear race to me anyway.

Finally, there’s slower advancement (XP, AP, death toll, faction gain) to be considered.  Again, it comes down to whether or not this is an acceptable trade-off for playing free.  For me, sure it is.  I’m not in a rush to level, and if I was, I’m sure I’d be subscribed.

The other three tiers come in $10, $15, and $30 versions, and include better rewards, incentives, and crafting/advancement rates.  It’s interesting to note that the $10 rate includes everything that current $15 players get, so you can actually downgrade your subscription cost while retaining all of the benefits you currently enjoy.  Or you can stay at $15 and get more.  The $30 “Commander” edition is probably only going to appeal to a very limited niche of players who either have the money to blow and want an easier mode, or those that want to help out their friends and clan with the nifty aura that bestows faster crafting/xp/salvaging/harvesting rates to pals nearby.

Anyway, I’m pretty psyched, especially now that I won’t have to worry about another sub in October.  Fallen Earth is one of those games I’d like to play from time to time at my own pace instead of in a huge chunk, so this model is great for me.

I’m taking the weekend off to be with my family, so see you all on Tuesday!

8 thoughts on “Fallen Earth free is fine by me

  1. I see the reductions to xp, ap, craftign times etc etc as bonuses not penalties. When EQ2X launched Mrs Bhagpuss and I moved there onto new Silver accounts in order to have the restrictions. Having played EQ2 since beta, those restrictions revitalized the game for us and gave us six months of what felt almost like a brand new game.

    I didn’t play Fallen Earth for long enough to need that kind of spin to bring me back, but I certainly don’t see the restrictions as any kind of deterrent. I’m really looking forward to getting back in the saddle.

  2. Gah, it just makes me absolutely enraged when people cry about a free-to-play conversion not giving away enough for free. LOTRO was particularly bad, with all the people that bought a box and played for a couple of months (years earlier!) expecting all the quest packs for free. I had to rant about that one on my blog –

    Fair enough to criticize a company if you think their free-to-play model includes some unwise decisions – e.g. I thought it was unwise to make most of the classes for-pay in EQ2, because I didn’t think that selling something which you’d need to reroll to appreciate fitted with the “get people hooked, then try to get them to spend money” concept. But crying that they don’t give you enough for free? Never.

  3. Is there anything at all to buy piecemeal or is just tiers of subscription with one tier being free? I really do prefer ‘pay as you go’ to ‘you should subscribe’.

  4. I’m with SKapusniak on that one. I like the ability to pay for extra content, but judging from this it seems like the majors things you get from subbing just make the game easier. I like it though, you don’t run into immersion breaking moments where you need to buy currency to buy a quest pack.

    As for the complaining, I’m agitated but not surprised. People will complain about anything.

  5. I’m very surprised they are allowing free accounts to use the auction house, trade, and the help channel. Are they not worried about gold sellers because the player base in this game is small?

    Also I’m glad you are back in Fallen Earth Syp. I recall your posts from 2009. I just started playing the game for the first time about a month ago.
    Let us know if you do find a good clan as I am on the hunt for one myself.

  6. I am with bhagpuss. The reduced xp/ap/crafting times are bonuses. I will be back in the wasteland in October. My only worry/question/concern is how they think to make money out of the F2P. The free version seems to have all I ever need. Although I would love to throw some money their way again, I don’t see how.

  7. I’m greatly looking forward to this. I really like Fallen Earth and have each time I’ve played it. I just can’t invest $15 a month into multiple titles.

    I think what we get for free is quite fair, personally. If you like the game enough that you’re hitting the limits they have then, you know, pay for it. It’s amazing what people want for nothing nowadays, but I guess it’s not a total surprise. For every pirate who claims they just don’t want DRM, there are 1,000 downloading DRM free copies of The Witcher 2. People seem to approach everything online with that mentality now.

  8. I think ultimately the lengthier harvesting / salvaging / crafting times, and limited crafting hours will be what gets people to upgrade. Having played the game off and on since launch, I always wished those features (particularly the first two) would be quicker. I suspect that’s what G1 is banking on, and I think they’re probably on target.

    The initial amount of content offered at the free level is staggeringly awesome, though, and I hope it draws a nice crowd. FE is a great game.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s