Posted in Try It Tuesday

Try It Tuesday: Tharsis

This week, I pulled out an Epic freebie that caught my eye: Tharsis. From the description, I thought this was going to be a sort of choose-your-own-adventure involving a spaceship to Mars. It sort of is, but not the way I assumed.

The entire game takes place during a multi-week mission to the Red Planet. At the start, the ship’s pantry module gets obliterated by a meteorite storm, several crew members are hurt, and food starts to run out. That’s the START of the game. The goal is to survive at any cost to make it to the end of the voyage.

Each turn, several nasty events hit the ship, and you have to allocate crew members to handle the problems. They do this by rolling six-sided dice to get enough numbers to meet the required number for the crisis. There are many rules involving the dice, including how to get more and how you can save some or use an “assist” to give you a boost or use a crew member’s innate ability to help out. But that’s the gist of it.

The problem is that there never seems to be enough dice — and enough food, which replenishes dice — to go around. Tharsis quickly, and almost gleefully, tells you that murder and cannibalism are an option. A gruesome detail is that any crew member who dines on the flesh of his or her crewmates ends up with blood-stained dice. That doesn’t affect anything that I could tell, other than to make the player feel guilty.

There’s a lot of strategy here, including research and food growth and other odds and ends, but I never felt that the rushed tutorial did a good job explaining them. It kind of felt like a board game that your friend whipped out, rattled off a lot of instructions that went over your head, and then said, “Eh, let’s just play, you’ll figure it out.”

Me figuring this out meant that my crew were all dead and the ship destroyed by turn four. So I’m an awesome captain, all right.

After a second round, I figured that Tharsis isn’t that enjoyable and isn’t for me. It’s too random and a little too hard to figure out the strategies. The concept is good, but it’s always in the execution, yeah?

One thought on “Try It Tuesday: Tharsis

  1. I actually beat the game on the first go-around, but I don’t think it was particularly fun. It’s not really the RNG that’s the problem, but just that there isn’t a lot of depth or interesting decisions.

    If you try again though, there were three elements that are majorly important. First, Food, as you point out. No matter what’s going on with the ship, try to park at least one character in the greenhouse. You need at least one double roll (e.g. 3, 3) to get one Food, but can get another Food if you get a triple.

    Second, try to synergize crew “abilities.” For example, the captain restores one die to everyone (including himself) when you “use” a die showing 5 or 6. That means he basically never needs to use Food himself as long as you don’t have to use a high die to fix something, and you can slow down your Food needs if there’s a 2nd person in the same module as him.

    Third, don’t sleep on the Research part of the game in the bottom-left corner of the screen. This area lets you park “unused” dice (from 1-6) and then use said Research points to trigger one of the three abilities. One ability might be to auto-fix 18 points of damage to a module, for example, for 3 Research. After use, that particular Research option is replaced with something else. This will help you get ahead of the curve and possibly parking 3 people in the greenhouse, after which the rest of the game is probably a forgone conclusion.

    But yeah, not particularly fun. If you get ahead, the game becomes trivial. If you fall behind, losing either an entire crew member or just getting less dice to roll, it becomes exponentially harder to do anything. Which, okay, mimics real life, but isn’t great game mechanics.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s